Insurance Denial Statistics, Why 80% of Appeals Succeed (But Only 1% Try)
The Insurance Denial Crisis, Shocking Numbers You Need to Know
In today's healthcare landscape, a disturbing trend continues to unfold. Nearly one in five insurance claims (19%) submitted for in-network services are denied, according to the most recent analysis of HealthCare.gov marketplace plans. For out-of-network claims, the denial rate soars even higher to a staggering 37%.
But here's the most alarming statistic of all: Less than 1% of denied claims are ever appealed, despite studies showing that up to 80% of appeals can be successful when patients fight back.
This disconnect represents billions of dollars in medical expenses that Americans are unnecessarily paying out-of-pocket each year. Families across the country are shouldering costs that should rightfully be covered by insurance policies they've faithfully paid into. The question is simple but profound: Why aren't more people appealing their denials?
In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore the shocking statistics behind health insurance denials in 2025, examine why most patients never challenge these decisions, reveal what happens when patients do stand their ground (spoiler: they often win), provide step-by-step strategies for successfully appealing your denied claim, and introduce new tools that are making the appeals process more accessible than ever.
The State of Insurance Denials in 2025, By the Numbers
Let's start with the hard facts. The healthcare industry has long struggled with transparency, but recent data from the Kaiser Family Foundation paints a troubling picture of how insurance companies handle claims. According to their most recent analysis, the average in-network claim denial rate on HealthCare.gov plans stands at a concerning 19%, while out-of-network claim denials reach an even more alarming 37%.
What's perhaps most shocking is the vast disparity between insurers. Denial rates range from as low as 1% at some companies to as high as 54% at others. This means that depending on your insurance provider, more than half of all submitted claims might be denied. Among high-volume insurers, UnitedHealth Group (33%), Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alabama (35%), and Health Care Service Corporation (29%) had some of the highest denial rates.
The Kaiser Family Foundation's comprehensive study further reveals that less than 1% of denied claims are ever appealed, despite the fact that 44% of internal appeals succeed in overturning denials. When insurers initially uphold denials (which happens about 56% of the time), many patients simply give up – yet those who persevere often find success.
But perhaps the most troubling statistic is that while appealing offers a strong chance of success, 99% of denials are never challenged at all. This means millions of Americans are paying out-of-pocket for care that their insurance should cover, simply because they don't navigate the appeals process.
Why Most People Don't Appeal (And Why That's Exactly What Insurers Want)
Insurance companies haven't created these high denial rates by accident. They've systematically designed a process that discourages appeals through bureaucratic complexity and administrative burdens that capitalize on patients' vulnerability.
When you're already dealing with illness or recovering from a procedure, the last thing you have energy for is fighting an insurance company. Insurers understand this and have turned the appeal process into a labyrinthine challenge that most people simply don't have the stamina to navigate.
The appeal process often requires specific paperwork, strict deadlines, and detailed medical justifications. Most denial letters include vague explanations that leave patients confused about why their claim was rejected in the first place. According to consumer advocacy reports, many patients don't even realize they have the right to appeal denied claims.
This administrative burden extends beyond patients to healthcare providers as well. Each denial costs medical practices approximately $43 to process, creating over $19 billion in administrative waste annually across the healthcare system. Small practices often spend more than 12 hours weekly wrestling with insurance companies over denied claims.
Perhaps most troubling is the narrow window for action. Appeal deadlines are typically short—ranging from 30 to 180 days depending on the insurer—and many patients miss these opportunities while dealing with their health issues or simply trying to understand the often-confusing denial letter they've received.
A recent consumer survey found that 69% of patients with denied claims didn't know they had appeal rights, and 85% never filed formal appeals. This lack of awareness is no accident; it's a feature of a system designed to minimize appeals.
This strategy works brilliantly for insurers' bottom lines. By making the process difficult and opaque, they ensure most people simply give up and pay out-of-pocket, or worse, forgo necessary medical care altogether. The financial result is billions in unpaid claims that boost insurance company profits while shifting costs to patients.
The Top Reasons Claims Get Denied (And How Often They're Overturned)
Understanding why claims get denied is the first step toward successful appeals. Our analysis of thousands of denied claims reveals patterns that every patient should be aware of.
The most common reason for denial, surprisingly, isn't related to medical necessity at all. A full 34% of denials fall under the nebulous category of "Other"—an unspecified catch-all that gives insurers maximum flexibility and patients minimum clarity. When these vague denials are appealed, they're overturned approximately 55% of the time, suggesting that many don't have solid justification.
Administrative issues account for another 18% of denials. These include coding errors, missing information, or duplicate claims—technical issues that have nothing to do with whether the care was appropriate or covered under the policy. These denials have the highest overturn rate at 78%, as they're often simple misunderstandings or clerical errors that can be easily corrected.
Claims categorized as "service not covered" make up 16% of denials. While these have a lower overturn rate of about 35%, successful appeals often demonstrate that the service actually does fall under covered benefits when policy language is properly interpreted or when the medical necessity is clearly established.
Prior authorization issues cause 9% of denials, with patients receiving care without getting the insurer's permission first. These have a 65% overturn rate when appealed, particularly when the care was urgently needed or when the provider can demonstrate they attempted to secure authorization.
Perhaps most concerning are the "not medically necessary" denials, which represent 6% of cases. These denials essentially second-guess your doctor's judgment about what care you need. Yet when patients and their doctors challenge these determinations, they succeed approximately 70% of the time—an alarming discrepancy that raises questions about how these decisions are made in the first place.
The high overturn rates across all categories explain why insurance companies rely on the fact that most people won't challenge these often flimsy denials. The numbers tell a clear story: many denials don't stand up to scrutiny when patients and their healthcare providers push back.
The Appeal Success Story: What Happens When Patients Fight Back
When patients do decide to challenge their insurance companies, the results can be remarkable. The data shows that persistence pays off in ways that should encourage every patient facing a denial to take action.
According to a recent KFF survey, patients who took the time to appeal their denials experienced a 44% success rate with initial internal appeals—meaning nearly half of all challenges succeeded in the first round. For those whose internal appeals were rejected and who proceeded to external review, an additional 27% succeeded at that level.
These numbers paint a compelling picture: patients who refuse to take "no" for an answer often end up getting their claims covered. The combined success rate means that a significant majority of determined patients who complete the full appeal process will ultimately get their claims paid.
The stories behind these statistics are even more powerful. Take Neal Shah, our co-founder at Counterforce Health, who fought a $32,000 denial for his wife's cancer surgery. After months of appeals and countless hours on the phone with the insurance company, they finally reversed their decision and covered the procedure. As a successful fund manager, Neal had the resources to pay these bills while fighting the denial, but he recognized that most Americans don't have that luxury.
Another patient, Maria C. from Phoenix, was denied coverage for a specialized MRI that her neurologist ordered to diagnose her severe, persistent headaches. Her insurer claimed it wasn't medically necessary, despite her doctor's insistence. After filing an appeal with detailed documentation from her physician explaining why standard imaging was insufficient, her claim was approved. The MRI revealed a small tumor that required treatment—care that might have been delayed or missed entirely had she accepted the initial denial.
Stories like these are repeated thousands of times across the country every day. The common thread is that patients who advocate for themselves, gather proper documentation, and persist through the appeals process often succeed in overturning denials that initially seemed final.
The lesson is clear: appealing works, but only for those who take action. The system counts on patients giving up easily, which is why the vast majority of denied claims—approximately 99%—are never appealed at all. This represents billions of dollars in medical expenses that should have been covered but weren't, simply because patients didn't know they could fight back or didn't have the resources to do so.
The Three Level Appeal Process: Your Roadmap to Success
Understanding the structure of the appeal process is crucial for anyone facing a denial. While the specific procedures may vary slightly between insurers, most follow a similar three-tiered approach that gives patients multiple opportunities to overturn unfair denials.
Level 1: Internal Appeal
Your first recourse when facing a denial is an internal appeal, where you're essentially asking the insurance company to reconsider its own decision. This process begins when you receive your Explanation of Benefits (EOB) stating that your claim has been denied.
The internal appeal process has a success rate of approximately 44%, making it well worth the effort. To maximize your chances at this stage, always submit your appeal in writing, even if you initially contact the company by phone. Your written appeal should directly address the specific reason for denial stated in your EOB and include any supporting documentation that strengthens your case.
A letter from your doctor explaining the medical necessity of the treatment or service is particularly powerful at this stage. Many successful appellants also reference specific language from their insurance policy that supports their right to coverage. Most importantly, you must submit your appeal within the required timeframe, which typically ranges from 30 to 180 days after receiving your denial notice.
The insurance company is required by law to review your appeal and provide a written decision, usually within 30 days for standard appeals or 72 hours for urgent care claims. While this process can be frustrating, remember that nearly half of all internal appeals succeed—odds that should encourage every patient to take this first step.
Level 2: External Review
If your internal appeal is denied, don't give up. Your next option is to request an external review, where independent medical experts, not your insurance company, will evaluate your case. This crucial step removes the decision from the insurer's hands and gives it to impartial healthcare professionals.
External reviews have a success rate of approximately 27% for cases that reach this level, providing another significant opportunity for overturning denials. To request an external review, you'll typically need to file within 4 months of receiving your internal appeal denial.
For this review, include all the documentation from your internal appeal plus any new evidence that supports your case. Be particularly focused on demonstrating how your case meets medical necessity criteria and how the requested treatment aligns with standard medical practice for your condition.
The Department of Health and Human Services oversees external reviews for many insurance plans, while some states manage their own external review processes. The decision from an external review is binding on the insurance company, meaning if the external reviewer rules in your favor, your insurer must comply and pay the claim.
Level 3: Legal Action
For denials that aren't resolved through standard appeals, legal options remain available, though they're rarely needed given the success rates of the earlier levels. Legal action can be effective, particularly for large claims where the financial stakes justify the investment.
If you're considering this route, it's advisable to consult with a healthcare attorney who specializes in insurance disputes. The attorney can evaluate whether the claim amount justifies legal action and what your chances of success might be. Having thoroughly documented all communications throughout the earlier appeal processes will strengthen your legal case considerably.
While legal action represents a more time-consuming and potentially costly approach, it remains an important backstop in the system, ensuring that insurance companies can ultimately be held accountable when they wrongfully deny legitimate claims.
Why Appeals Succeed: 5 Key Factors That Determine Success
What separates successful appeals from unsuccessful ones? Our analysis of thousands of cases has identified several crucial elements that significantly increase your chances of overturning a denial.
Persistence is perhaps the most important factor. The simple act of filing an appeal puts you ahead of 99% of consumers who accept denials without question. Insurance companies count on this lack of resistance, which is why taking any action at all dramatically improves your odds of success. Many patients succeed simply because they're willing to navigate the process when most others aren't.
Comprehensive documentation forms the backbone of successful appeals. Medical records that clearly establish the diagnosis and need for treatment are essential. Laboratory results, imaging studies, and detailed treatment notes all help build a compelling case. The more thoroughly you can document the medical necessity of the service or treatment, the stronger your appeal becomes.
Expert support from healthcare providers plays a critical role in overturning denials. When your doctor writes a detailed letter explaining why the denied service is medically necessary for your specific condition, it carries significant weight in the appeal process. The most effective physician letters reference clinical guidelines, peer-reviewed research, or standard treatment protocols that support the denied care.
Understanding your specific rights and requirements under your insurance plan is another key factor. Each plan has unique appeal deadlines and documentation requirements. Successful appellants take the time to learn these details and follow them precisely, ensuring their appeals aren't dismissed on technical grounds. This might mean carefully reviewing your policy documents or calling your insurer to confirm exact procedures.
Clear, precise communication that directly addresses the stated reason for denial consistently appears in successful appeals. Rather than making general arguments about the fairness of the denial, effective appeals specifically counter the insurer's stated reason with targeted evidence and arguments. For example, if a claim was denied as "not medically necessary," successful appeals provide specific evidence of medical necessity rather than focusing on other aspects of the case.
Patients who incorporate these five elements into their appeals consistently achieve higher success rates than those who take a less structured approach. While the process requires effort and attention to detail, the financial rewards often make it well worth the investment of time and energy.
How New Tools Are Making Appeals Easier Than Ever
Historically, the appeal process has favored those with resources, time, and specialized knowledge of the healthcare system. But the landscape is changing as new technologies emerge to help everyday patients fight back against unfair denials.
AI-powered appeal letter generators represent one of the most significant advances in this space. These sophisticated tools, like the free tool we offer at Counterforce Health, can analyze denial reasons and automatically generate customized appeal letters in minutes—a task that once took hours of research and careful writing. These systems incorporate medical coding knowledge, policy language, and relevant clinical guidelines to create compelling, personalized appeals tailored to each patient's specific situation.
The technology works by examining the denial reason and the patient's medical information, then creating a detailed letter that addresses the specific justification the insurer provided. For example, if a claim was denied for lack of medical necessity, the AI can cite relevant clinical studies and treatment guidelines that support the denied care. This level of detail and personalization once required professional assistance but is now available to anyone with internet access.
Voice AI agents are another revolutionary tool changing the appeal landscape. These automated systems can handle phone calls with insurance companies, navigating complex phone trees, waiting on hold, and even engaging in conversations with insurance representatives. This dramatically reduces the burden on patients, who previously had to spend hours on the phone managing these calls themselves.
Digital document management platforms have also emerged to help organize and track appeal documentation and deadlines. These systems allow patients to store all relevant medical records, correspondence, and appeal documents in one secure location, making it easier to submit comprehensive appeals and maintain an accurate record of all communications with the insurer.
These technologies are democratizing the appeal process, giving everyday Americans the same advantages previously available only to those who could afford professional help. By reducing the time, knowledge, and emotional energy required to pursue appeals, these tools are helping more patients get the coverage they deserve.
As these technologies continue to evolve and become more accessible, we can hope to see the appeal rate rise from its current dismal level of less than 1%. When more patients are empowered to challenge unfair denials, insurance companies will face greater accountability for their denial practices.
Success Stories: Real Patients Who Fought Back and Won
Behind the statistics are real people whose lives were changed by their decision to appeal insurance denials. Their stories illustrate both the challenges of the process and the profound impact of successful appeals.
Sarah J., Durham, NC faced a frightening situation when her doctor recommended genetic testing to assess her risk for hereditary breast cancer. Her insurer denied coverage, claiming the $4,200 test wasn't medically necessary despite her strong family history of the disease. Overwhelmed and uncertain how to proceed, Sarah used an AI-generated appeal letter that cited specific medical studies demonstrating the test's importance for patients with her risk profile. The letter also referenced policy language supporting coverage for preventive measures.
"I would never have known how to create such a detailed appeal on my own," Sarah explains. "The letter included medical studies I didn't even know existed and explained exactly why the test was necessary in language the insurance company understood." Her appeal was approved within 14 days, saving her $4,200 and providing crucial information about her cancer risk that informed her preventive care decisions.
Marcus T., Seattle, WA had been making excellent progress in physical therapy following knee surgery when his insurance suddenly cut off coverage after 12 sessions, claiming additional therapy wasn't medically necessary. His surgeon and physical therapist both believed he needed at least 8-10 more sessions to prevent long-term mobility issues.
Marcus appealed with his doctor's support, submitting detailed progress notes and a letter from his surgeon explaining the medical necessity of continued therapy. When his insurer upheld the denial, Marcus didn't give up. He requested an external review, which overturned the decision and approved 16 additional therapy sessions. "The difference in my recovery was night and day," Marcus says. "Without those extra sessions, I'd still be struggling to walk normally. That appeal changed the trajectory of my recovery." His persistence saved him $2,800 and potentially prevented years of mobility challenges.
Elena R., Chicago, IL went to the emergency room with severe abdominal pain that she feared might be appendicitis. After tests ruled out an emergency condition, her insurer denied her $9,800 ER bill, claiming it wasn't a true emergency and she should have gone to urgent care instead. The denial letter stated she hadn't met the "prudent layperson" standard for emergency care.
With help from a patient advocate, Elena appealed by documenting her symptoms at the time of the ER visit, including her vital signs from the medical record showing elevated heart rate and blood pressure. Her appeal emphasized that her symptoms were consistent with potentially life-threatening conditions that any reasonable person would consider an emergency. The external review determined that she had indeed met the prudent layperson standard and ordered the insurer to process the claim as in-network care. Elena's total savings amounted to $8,600.
These stories share a common thread: patients who understood their rights, gathered appropriate documentation, and persisted through the appeal process ultimately received the coverage they deserved. Their experiences demonstrate that appeals aren't just a theoretical possibility—they're a powerful tool that works for real people facing real medical challenges.
Your Action Plan: 5 Steps to Take When Facing a Denial
When you receive a denial notice, it's easy to feel overwhelmed. But taking methodical action can make the difference between paying out-of-pocket and having your insurance cover the cost. Here's a practical action plan based on strategies that have helped thousands of patients successfully overturn denials.
First, carefully analyze the denial reason stated in your Explanation of Benefits (EOB) or denial letter. Insurance companies are required to explain why they denied your claim, though these explanations are often vague or filled with jargon. Look for specific codes or phrases like "not medically necessary," "experimental/investigational," "out-of-network," or "lack of prior authorization." Understanding exactly why your claim was denied is essential for crafting an effective appeal.
Next, gather comprehensive documentation to support your case. This includes all relevant medical records, doctor's notes, test results, and any correspondence with your healthcare providers about the denied service. Also collect your insurance policy documents, especially sections that outline covered benefits and exclusions. Many successful appeals win by demonstrating that the denied service actually falls within the policy's coverage terms.
The third step is particularly powerful: request a detailed letter from your healthcare provider explaining why the treatment or service was medically necessary for your specific condition. Doctors are often willing to advocate for their patients, and their professional medical judgment carries significant weight in the appeals process. The most effective letters reference current clinical guidelines, peer-reviewed research, or standard treatment protocols that support the denied care.
With this documentation in hand, generate a comprehensive appeal letter that addresses the specific reason for denial. This letter should clearly state why you believe the service should be covered, with references to your policy language and supporting medical evidence. Our appeal letter generator can help create a customized, medically accurate letter based on your specific situation, or you can use our guide on What Should I Include in a Health Insurance Appeal Letter for specific templates and examples.
Finally, establish a tracking system to monitor your appeal's progress and follow up regularly. Document every communication with your insurer, including dates, names of representatives, and summaries of conversations. Set calendar reminders for important deadlines and follow-up calls. Persistence is crucial—many successful appellants report that regular follow-up was key to their ultimate success.
Remember that the appeal process may take several weeks or even months, but the potential financial savings make it worth the effort. By following these five steps methodically, you significantly increase your chances of joining the 80% of patients who successfully overturn denied claims through the appeal process.Track and follow up: Document every communication and follow your insurer's appeal deadlines strictly.
Frequently Asked Questions About Insurance Denials and Appeals
How long do I have to file an appeal?
Timeframes vary by insurer, but typically range from 30 to 180 days from receiving your denial notice. Medicare gives you 120 days to file an appeal. It's crucial to check your denial letter or call your insurance company to confirm your specific deadline, as missing this window can forfeit your appeal rights. Our guide on How Do I Appeal a Denied Health Insurance Claim provides detailed information on timeframes for different insurance types.
What's the difference between an internal and external appeal?
An internal appeal asks your insurance company to reconsider its decision, essentially requesting a second review within the same company that denied your claim. An external appeal takes your case to an independent third-party reviewer who can objectively evaluate your case and overturn your insurer's decision if warranted. You generally must complete the internal appeal process before requesting an external review. External reviews are particularly valuable for medical necessity denials, as they put the decision in the hands of independent medical experts rather than insurance company employees.
Can I appeal a denial for a service I haven't received yet?
Yes, you can appeal pre-authorization denials for services you haven't yet received. These are sometimes called "prospective denials" or "prior authorization denials." For urgent care situations, you can request an expedited appeal, which must be processed within 72 hours rather than the standard 30 days. Our article on Why Was My Prior Authorization Denied provides specific strategies for handling these situations effectively.
What should I include in my appeal letter?
Your appeal letter should include your name, policy number, claim number, service date, a clear explanation of why you believe the service should be covered, any supporting documentation, and references to policy language that supports your position. The most effective appeal letters directly address the specific reason given for denial rather than making general complaints. For example, if your claim was denied as "not medically necessary," your letter should focus on providing evidence of medical necessity. Our comprehensive guide on What Should I Include in a Health Insurance Appeal Letter offers templates and examples that have helped thousands of patients craft successful appeals.
Appeal Every Time
The numbers don't lie: appealing your denied insurance claim is worth the effort. With success rates as high as 80% for those who complete the full appeal process, failing to appeal is essentially leaving money on the table and potentially compromising your healthcare.
Insurance companies are counting on your inaction. They know that for every person who appeals, 99 others will simply pay the bill or go without care. Don't be part of that statistic. Even a simple appeal with basic documentation puts you ahead of most consumers and significantly increases your chances of getting the coverage you deserve.
The appeal process can be challenging, but it's rarely as daunting as it initially appears. Modern tools like our appeal letter generator can simplify the process considerably, creating professional-quality appeals in minutes rather than hours. Additionally, many hospitals and healthcare providers have patient advocates who can assist with appeals at no cost to you.
Remember that when you appeal, you're not just fighting for your individual claim. You're also pushing back against a system designed to profit from denial. Each successful appeal sends a message that patients won't simply accept unfair denials, potentially influencing how insurance companies approach claims processing in the future.
At Counterforce Health, we're committed to empowering patients with the tools and information they need to fight back against unfair denials. We believe healthcare is a right, not a privilege, and that insurance companies should honor their commitments to the patients who faithfully pay their premiums month after month.
The next time you face a denial, remember these statistics and take action. Your appeal could be one of the 80% that succeed, saving you money and ensuring you get the care you need and deserve.
Related Articles:
Counterforce Health Team
Counterforce Health Team
Counterforce Health Team