United Healthcare Medicare Advantage Investigation 2025: Member Rights During DOJ Criminal Probe
In mid-May 2025, United Healthcare found itself at the center of a reported Department of Justice (DOJ) criminal investigation into its Medicare Advantage business practices. This development came just days after CEO Andrew Witty's sudden resignation and the company's suspension of its 2025 financial forecast, leaving millions of Medicare Advantage members concerned about their coverage security.
While UnitedHealth Group has denied being notified of any criminal investigation and stands by "the integrity of [their] Medicare Advantage program," the company's stock has plummeted over 15% following the report. For the 31.2 million Americans enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans, uncertainty about what these developments mean for their healthcare coverage creates significant anxiety.
This guide explains what the investigation potentially means for UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage members, outlines your specific rights during a federal investigation, and provides actionable steps to protect your healthcare coverage during this uncertain period.
Understanding the UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Investigation
Timeline of Recent UnitedHealth Group Developments
The current situation follows months of mounting scrutiny of UnitedHealth Group. In December 2024, UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson was fatally shot in New York, sparking nationwide discussions about frustrations with insurance denials. By February 2025, The Wall Street Journal reported that the DOJ had initiated a civil fraud investigation into UnitedHealth's Medicare Advantage billing practices.
The pressure intensified in April 2025 when UnitedHealth cut its 2025 forecast after missing quarterly earnings expectations for the first time in over a decade. Then on May 14, 2025, CEO Andrew Witty abruptly resigned, and UnitedHealth suspended its 2025 financial outlook. Just one day later, The Wall Street Journal reported a DOJ criminal investigation into UnitedHealth's Medicare Advantage business practices.
UnitedHealth quickly responded that it "had not been notified by the Department of Justice of the supposed criminal investigation" and called the reporting "deeply irresponsible." Nevertheless, the company's stock continued to fall.
The investigation reportedly focuses on how UnitedHealthcare records diagnoses that trigger extra payments to its Medicare Advantage plans. According to previous Wall Street Journal reporting, UnitedHealth allegedly received billions in additional federal funds for diagnoses that patients were never treated for.
What Makes This Investigation Different
While UnitedHealth has faced previous scrutiny, the reported escalation to a criminal investigation represents a significant development. The difference between civil and criminal investigations is substantial. Civil investigations typically focus on recovering government funds and imposing financial penalties. Criminal investigations, however, can potentially lead to more severe consequences, including criminal charges against corporations or individuals.
This probe comes amid broader federal scrutiny of the Medicare Advantage program. Just weeks ago, the DOJ filed a False Claims Act complaint against three other major insurers (Aetna, Elevance Health, and Humana) for allegedly paying kickbacks to brokers who steered patients into their Medicare Advantage plans.
Your Rights as a UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Member
Despite the investigation, UnitedHealthcare must continue to provide the coverage and benefits outlined in your plan documents. Medicare Advantage organizations operate under strict federal regulations that protect members, even when the company is under investigation.
Coverage Guarantees During Federal Investigations
Federal regulations provide several key protections for Medicare Advantage members. UnitedHealthcare must fulfill all contract obligations with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and cannot reduce benefits or increase costs during a plan year. These service continuity requirements mean plans must maintain access to covered services throughout the contract period.
Perhaps most importantly, UnitedHealthcare cannot terminate your coverage based on health status or health care needs. According to Medicare.gov, "If you disagree with a coverage or payment decision by your Medicare Advantage or other Medicare health plan, you can file an appeal." This right remains fully intact regardless of any ongoing investigations.
Network Access Protections
UnitedHealthcare must maintain adequate provider networks throughout any investigation. The plans must maintain enough providers to deliver all covered benefits without unreasonable delay. Access to specialty providers must be maintained within reasonable time and distance standards, and if your provider leaves the network, UnitedHealthcare must allow continued treatment for specific conditions.
All Medicare Advantage plans must cover emergency care at any facility, regardless of network status. These protections ensure you maintain access to necessary care despite any corporate turmoil or investigation. The CMS Medicare Managed Care Manual outlines these network adequacy requirements in detail.
Financial Protections for Medicare Advantage Members
Medicare regulations include financial protections that remain in force throughout the plan year. Your plan's maximum out-of-pocket limit for in-network services cannot change mid-year. Monthly premiums must remain stable, and your established cost-sharing amounts for copayments and coinsurance must remain the same. Additionally, the drug formulary cannot be substantially altered mid-year, protecting your access to necessary medications.
The Office of Inspector General (OIG) at HHS regularly reviews Medicare Advantage organizations for compliance with these beneficiary protection requirements.
Practical Steps to Protect Your Healthcare Coverage
In times of uncertainty, taking proactive steps can help safeguard your access to care.
Documenting Your Current Benefits and Approvals
Create a healthcare documentation file that includes comprehensive records of your current coverage. Keep a copy of your Evidence of Coverage and Summary of Benefits for reference. Save all written approval notices for ongoing treatments and procedures.
Request written confirmation that your doctors remain in-network, especially for specialists managing chronic conditions. Document your prescription drug approvals and formulary status, particularly for high-cost or specialty medications. Keep detailed notes of all communications with UnitedHealthcare, including representative names, dates, and reference numbers.
According to a KFF Health News report, when navigating insurance complications, "documentation becomes your most powerful asset during disputes." This documentation provides essential evidence if you later need to file an appeal.
Monitoring Your Claims and Benefits
Watch closely for changes in how UnitedHealthcare processes your claims. Note any unusual delays in claim processing compared to their typical timeframes. Review each Explanation of Benefits (EOB) carefully for unexpected denials or new limitations on coverage. Document how long authorization requests take, and be alert for new patterns of denials for previously covered services.
Changes in processing patterns could signal operational issues related to the investigation, or potentially, new internal policies affecting coverage decisions. By monitoring closely, you can identify problems early and address them proactively.
Creating a Healthcare Continuity Plan
Develop a backup plan to ensure continuous care regardless of what happens with the investigation. Work with your doctor to obtain 90-day supplies of critical medications where possible to ensure you don't run out during any disruption. Consider scheduling important treatments and procedures sooner rather than later, particularly those requiring prior authorization.
If you anticipate needing specialist care, request referrals now rather than waiting until an urgent need arises. Request copies of your medical records from all providers to have on hand if you need to demonstrate medical necessity or continuity of care. This preparation ensures you can continue receiving necessary treatment even if processing delays or other administrative issues occur.
Appeal Rights and Strategies During Federal Investigations
If you face a coverage denial during this period, understanding the appeal process is essential.
Medicare Advantage Standard Appeal Process
The standard Medicare Advantage appeal process includes multiple levels of review to ensure fair consideration of your case. First, request that UnitedHealthcare reconsider the denial through an internal appeal. If denied again, your case automatically goes to an Independent Review Entity for external evaluation.
For cases involving at least $180, you can request a hearing with an Administrative Law Judge if the previous levels uphold the denial. If still denied, you can request a review by the Medicare Appeals Council. Finally, for cases involving at least $1,900, you can file a lawsuit in federal court.
For urgent care issues, you can request an expedited appeal that must be decided within 72 hours. This faster process ensures that time-sensitive medical needs aren't delayed by bureaucratic processes. The Medicare Rights Center provides detailed guidance on navigating this process.
Appeal Strategies Specific to Companies Under Investigation
When appealing denials from a company under investigation, strategic approaches can increase your chances of success. Reference coverage rules explicitly by citing specific sections of your Evidence of Coverage that support your case. Include detailed letters from your healthcare providers documenting medical necessity and explaining why the treatment is appropriate.
If the service was previously approved, emphasize this fact to demonstrate inconsistency in coverage decisions. Show how the requested care follows Medicare guidelines or established clinical practice guidelines. Keep your appeal direct and factual, avoiding emotional language and focusing on the specific coverage rules that support your position.
A Commonwealth Fund study found that when Medicare Advantage beneficiaries appeal denials, plans overturn approximately 75% of their own denials upon review, suggesting that appealing is often worthwhile. This high overturn rate indicates that many initial denials are inappropriate and can be successfully challenged.
External Review Options and Regulatory Complaints
Beyond the standard appeal process, you have additional options to resolve coverage issues. File a complaint with your state insurance commissioner, who oversees insurance practices within your state. Submit a complaint directly to Medicare through 1-800-MEDICARE to alert federal regulators to potential problems.
If you suspect discrimination in coverage decisions, file a complaint with the HHS Office for Civil Rights. You can also contact your congressional representatives for assistance, as their constituent services often help navigate federal program issues. These external avenues create additional pressure for fair treatment and can sometimes resolve issues more quickly than standard appeals.
Evaluating Alternative Coverage Options
While an investigation alone doesn't necessarily warrant changing your coverage, understanding your options is prudent.
Special Enrollment Period Eligibility
Under certain circumstances, you may qualify for a Special Enrollment Period (SEP) to change plans outside the Annual Enrollment Period. You can switch to a Medicare Advantage plan with a 5-star rating once per year, regardless of when you make the change. CMS occasionally grants SEPs for exceptional situations affecting large numbers of beneficiaries.
If you relocate outside your plan's service area, you qualify for an SEP to select new coverage. Similarly, if UnitedHealthcare were to terminate your plan, you would receive an SEP to choose alternative coverage. While the investigation itself doesn't automatically qualify you for an SEP, these other pathways may become relevant depending on how the situation evolves. The AARP Medicare Resource Center provides comprehensive information on Special Enrollment Periods.
Comparing Other Medicare Advantage Plans
If considering a switch, evaluate potential plans carefully with several factors in mind. Research other insurers' financial health and regulatory history to avoid moving to another company with similar issues. Verify that your doctors participate in alternative plans before making any change to maintain continuity of care.
Compare coverage for your specific medications and treatments to ensure comparable benefits. Review Medicare's star ratings for other available plans as an indicator of overall quality and member satisfaction. This thorough evaluation helps ensure that any change you make represents an improvement rather than simply trading one set of problems for another.
Traditional Medicare with Supplemental Coverage
Consider whether Original Medicare with a supplement might provide more stability in this uncertain environment. Original Medicare allows you to see any provider who accepts Medicare, without network restrictions. Supplement insurance (Medigap) policies can reduce out-of-pocket costs for services covered by Medicare.
You'll need a separate Part D prescription drug plan for medication coverage, as Original Medicare doesn't include drug benefits. Compare total costs including premiums, deductibles, and potential out-of-pocket expenses to understand the financial implications of making this change. For some beneficiaries, especially those with complex health needs, the predictability of Original Medicare with a supplement may outweigh the additional benefits often included in Medicare Advantage plans.
The National Council on Aging offers a detailed comparison guide to help weigh these options.
Expert Recommendations and Next Steps
Based on the current situation, healthcare policy experts recommend taking a measured approach that balances preparation with patience.
Short-term Action Items
Document your current benefits in detail, creating a reference file of your coverage terms, network providers, and any ongoing treatment authorizations. Refill important prescriptions as soon as allowed under your plan to maintain an adequate supply of critical medications.
Schedule any pending procedures or specialist visits that you've been considering, particularly those that might require prior authorization. Verify the network status of your key providers by contacting them directly to confirm their continued participation with UnitedHealthcare. Review your Evidence of Coverage thoroughly to understand your specific benefits and rights under the plan.
Medium-term Monitoring Strategy
Follow news about the investigation and UnitedHealthcare's responses to stay informed about developments that might affect your coverage. Watch for communications from UnitedHealthcare or CMS regarding any changes or updates to your plan.
Track your claims and Explanations of Benefits carefully for any changes in processing patterns or unexpected denials. Maintain detailed records of all healthcare services received, including dates, providers, diagnosis codes, and treatment recommendations. This documentation creates a paper trail that can support appeals if necessary.
Long-term Contingency Planning
Research alternative coverage options in your area, including other Medicare Advantage plans and Original Medicare with supplements. Mark your calendar for the Annual Enrollment Period (October 15-December 7) when you can change plans without needing a qualifying event.
Consider consulting with a State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) counselor for free, unbiased guidance specific to your situation. Build relationships with your healthcare providers' billing offices, as they can be valuable allies in navigating coverage issues and supporting appeals when needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Will the UnitedHealthcare criminal investigation affect my current coverage?
A: No, your current coverage and benefits cannot legally be reduced during a plan year. UnitedHealthcare must continue to provide all covered services as outlined in your Evidence of Coverage.
Q: Can I switch my Medicare Advantage plan outside of open enrollment due to the investigation?
A: Generally, an investigation alone doesn't qualify you for a Special Enrollment Period. However, you can switch to a 5-star rated Medicare Advantage plan at any time during the year, and CMS occasionally grants special enrollment periods for exceptional circumstances.
Q: What should I do if UnitedHealthcare denies a claim I believe should be covered?
A: File an appeal immediately. Request a formal reconsideration from UnitedHealthcare, include documentation of medical necessity from your provider, and follow the appeal deadlines carefully. Contact your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) for free, personalized guidance.
Q: Could the investigation result in UnitedHealthcare exiting the Medicare Advantage market?
A: While significant changes are possible long-term, Medicare Advantage organizations must provide significant notice before exiting markets. CMS also has procedures to protect members if a plan terminates.
Q: How do I know if my doctor will continue accepting UnitedHealthcare during the investigation?
A: Contact your providers directly to confirm their network status and commitment to UnitedHealthcare. Get written confirmation if possible, especially for any scheduled procedures or ongoing treatments.
Q: What evidence should I collect if UnitedHealthcare denies my Medicare Advantage claim?
A: Gather your denial letter, relevant medical records, a letter of medical necessity from your doctor, your plan's Evidence of Coverage showing the benefit should be covered, and documentation of any previous approvals for similar services.
Q: Can UnitedHealthcare increase my premiums or reduce my benefits because of the investigation?
A: No. Your benefits and premiums are locked in for the calendar year. Medicare regulations prohibit mid-year benefit reductions or premium increases.
Take Action to Protect Your Healthcare Rights
While the UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage investigation creates uncertainty, understanding your rights and taking proactive steps can help ensure your healthcare needs remain met. Remember that regardless of any investigation, you retain full appeal rights and coverage guarantees under federal law.
At Counterforce Health, we're committed to empowering patients to fight back against unfair insurance practices. If you're facing denials or have concerns about your coverage during this period, our AI-powered appeal tools can help you generate effective appeal letters in minutes.
Have you experienced claim denials from UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage? Share your experience in the comments below.
This blog post aims to provide general information about healthcare coverage rights during an investigation. It does not constitute legal advice. For personalized assistance with Medicare issues, contact your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) at 1-877-839-2675 or visit shiphelp.org.
Did you find this article helpful? Counterforce Health is dedicated to fighting unfair insurance denials. Check out our related resources:
Counterforce Health Team
Counterforce Health Team
Counterforce Health Team
Counterforce Health Team
Counterforce Health Team